The four-card trick
Privatisation and "public-private partnerships" are sold with words that sound like common sense —
efficiency, risk transfer, no cost to taxpayers, unlocking capital. Here is what each phrase hides,
each unpacked with sources on its own page.
1. "The private sector runs it more efficiently."
Government borrows more cheaply than any company alive. When you hand a monopoly to private
investors, they must earn a return on equity — often 8–15% — on top of
their higher borrowing costs. That gap doesn't come from magic efficiency; it comes out of
your tolls, fares and bills. The UK's own auditor found its PFI hospitals and schools
cost around 40% more than public financing. See how the deal works →
2. "It transfers the risk off the taxpayer."
Only until it doesn't. When private toll roads went bust on fantasy traffic forecasts —
Cross City Tunnel, Lane Cove Tunnel, Brisbane's Clem7 and AirportLink — the
early investors were wiped out, but the road kept tolling, sold cheap to the next owner.
When a PPP hospital operator collapsed, the government had to step back in. Profit is private;
catastrophe is shared. Follow the socialised losses →
3. "It costs the public nothing — it's private money."
It's your money. Industry-super vehicles like IFM Investors and funds
like AustralianSuper own big stakes in the airports, ports, power networks and
toll roads. So you pay a toll to a road your own retirement savings own — and the fund skims a
management fee off the top on the way past. You paid to build it, you pay to use it, and you pay
to own it. See how your super buys it back →
4. "It's a normal commercial deal — nothing to see."
Then why can't you read it? PPP contracts are routinely stamped
"commercial-in-confidence" and released only in redacted form, years late.
Auditors-general have complained for two decades that the secrecy makes value-for-money
impossible to check. The deal is done in your name, with your assets, but not in your sight.
See what's redacted →
The machine, in one loop
Once you see it, you can't unsee it. The same dollar leaves you three times and comes back to the
same small circle of players every time.
Public builds the assetyour parents' taxes
→
Government sells / leases it"budget repair"
→
You pay tolls & billsCPI-locked, rising
→
Your super buys the assetand charges you a fee
↺
Politicians call it a win
Every step is defensible on its own. Put together, it's a mechanism for moving public wealth into
private hands and calling it reform — while the price you pay to move, to keep the lights on and to
ship goods across the country ratchets up faster than inflation, as the cost of living.
See the inflation machine →
What this site is — and isn't
This is not an argument that every road should be free or that private capital is evil. It's a
demand for honesty and consent. Some of these deals may even have been worth
doing. But they were struck in secret, priced against forecasts that turned out to be fiction,
escalated above inflation by contract, and — increasingly — sold back to the public through their
own compulsory savings, all without anyone ever putting the question to a vote.
Every figure here is drawn from the public record: auditors-general, the ACCC, the energy and
pricing regulators, budget papers, company filings and reputable reporting. Where a number is a
government or company claim, contested, or illustrative, it's labelled
as such. Start with how a PPP actually works, or jump to
the sources.
Know where a body is buried?
We work with whistleblowers inside treasuries, super funds, infrastructure managers and toll
operators. Confidential contact: whistle@theradicalparty.com.